October Cookie Experience 2026

$39.00

A spooky-sweet box of specialty cookies created exclusively for October! You’ll get one decorated skeleton cookie in a tiny casket, four giant bakery-style cookies, a Halloween surprise, and a secret sneak peek at what’s coming next. Only 10 boxes available!

Want to keep the contents a surprise? Stop scrolling! There are spoilers below.

Scroll down for the full Cookie Experience, what’s included, important details, and all the delicious spoilers.

Only 2 left in stock

Description

The October Cookie Experience

A little spooky. A little sweet. And very delicious.

Welcome to the very first Cookie Experience from Pastry Shells!

Each month, I’ll create a limited-edition box filled with specialty cookies, fun surprises, and a whole lot of deliciousness. For October, we’re kicking things off with a Halloween box that’s spooky on the outside and seriously indulgent on the inside.

This is my very first Cookie Experience, and I’m starting with just 10 boxes!

But first, a very important warning…

If you want your October box to be a surprise, STOP SCROLLING!

Seriously.

There are spoilers below.

If you don’t mind knowing exactly what’s inside, keep going. If you want to experience the full surprise when your box arrives, go back up and place your order!

What’s Inside Your October Cookie Experience?

The Skeleton in the Casket

Your box begins with a chocolate sugar cookie decorated as a skeleton, tucked inside its very own custom casket.

Yes, I made a tiny casket specifically for a cookie.

Because apparently a regular cookie box wasn’t spooky enough.

It’s a delicious chocolate sugar cookie decorated by hand and packaged as the creepy-cute centerpiece of your October experience.

Frankenstein’s Cookie

This isn’t your average Frankenstein cookie.

This giant green cookie is stuffed with a cookie dough center and loaded with white chocolate, Oreos, and Biscoff cookie.

It’s gooey, crunchy, creamy, chocolatey, and basically everything Halloween should be.

Pumpkin & Oat Cookie

A soft, cozy Pumpkin & Oat Cookie with a surprise hiding inside: a cream cheese-stuffed center.

Think pumpkin spice season meets cheesecake, all wrapped up in one giant cookie.

S’mores Cookie

We’re taking s’mores and turning them into one seriously loaded cookie.

This cookie is packed with chocolate chips, graham crackers, and marshmallow, with a generous amount of marshmallow stuffed right into the center.

It’s basically campfire s’mores without having to sit next to a campfire.

Brownie Cookie

For the chocolate lovers.

A rich, fudgy brownie-style chocolate cookie loaded with chocolate chips.

Because every Halloween box needs at least one cookie that is unapologetically chocolate.

And That’s Not All…

The cookies are just part of the experience.

Your box will also include:

A Halloween-themed Pastry Shells freebie

A beautifully packaged menu card with everything included in your box and a little story behind this month’s treats.

A TOP SECRET envelope containing a sneak peek at what’s coming in next month’s Cookie Experience, along with a QR code so you’ll know how to get your hands on it.

Specially designed packaging created to make opening your box feel like an experience of its own.

Because I didn’t want to simply put some cookies in a box and call it a day.

I wanted you to have something fun to open, discover, and enjoy.

Your October Cookie Lineup

Chocolate Sugar Cookie Skeleton
Decorated by hand and tucked inside a custom casket.

Frankenstein Cookie
Cookie dough stuffed with white chocolate, Oreos, and Biscoff.

Pumpkin & Oat Cookie
Pumpkin and oat cookie with a cream cheese center.

S’mores Cookie
Chocolate chips, graham crackers, and marshmallow.

Brownie Cookie
Chocolate cookie loaded with chocolate chips.

Important Details

Shipping: Georgia only
Local Pickup: Dunwoody, Georgia
Quantity: Only 10 boxes available
Boxes ship: October 26
Pickup Dates: October 27-30 from 10AM – 8PM

Sold out? Join the waitlist to get first access to the next Monthly Cookie Experience!

 

Additional information

Weight 32 oz
Dimensions 9 × 6.5 × 2.75 in